I was sent this book for review. I wasn't totally thrilled with it. At first, I thought, 'Not another book about Avalon!' There are many references to Avalon in literature. It has taken me a bit of time to get through it.
It's not a bad plot, truthfully. The author tells us that the novel came to him in dreams, while on active service in the navy. It is an intriguing novel about what happens after 'happily ever after' of Avalon. Bringing in the Age of Technology. The war scenes are quite vivid, and creative, aside from the editing issues. I wish Piggott had done some research about Avalon and either stuck to it, or created a new world, rather than introducing the incongruous time frames.
Characterization and setting
It took me several hundred pages to really become immersed in the novel, it totals 537. The chapters jump back and forth in time, revolving around the life of the the *Gil-Gamesh, AKA Lord Bryan MoonDrake, a former commoner. I was uncomfortable trying to put the pieces in the plot together, since I hadn't read the first book. It is a puzzle, and I kept wondering what I'd missed, but that was just me! [*Gilgamesh was an historic king of Uruk, Mesopotamia, who lived sometime between 2800 and 2500 BCE. He is the main character in the Epic of Gilgamesh, an Akkadian poem.]
We need a strong protagonist and antagonist, which he has created in the Gil-Gamesh and Morgana le Fay. Yet, it is a different take on the world of Avalon. Many books have been written about this time, King Arthur and Guinevere were said to be in the year 500 C.E. (Common Era), a bit of an incongruous situation. Most of Piggott's characters come from dark forces created in myths and legends: knights, elves, dwarves, and include Latin and magical spells. They are well-crafted.
However, Gil-Gamesh visits Togo, in West Africa, and takes us into a real world place. I felt uncomfortable with the stereotypes of the Indigenous people. While the real Togo population has been the target of criticism of its human rights record, the characters in Togo made me uncomfortable. It would appear that the only characters of colour in the novel were those featured as tribal natives in Togo. I wasn't sure why suddenly we are introduced to a real tribe of people. Most of his characters are quite creative and magical (elves, dragons, and the like).
Themes Nautical and Religious
The Dark Tides does incorporate some interesting nautical premises. This was the most creative aspect of the novel. How many of us have had dreams of flying and airships?! This is where the author's expertise fascinated me. However, the incorporation of the religious themes made me uncomfortable. Piggott writes about this in a blog post. I kept thinking about all the novels I'd read about Avalon, traditionally inhabited by nine priestesses, known for their mystical and healing abilities. I adored these powerful women, and their Celtic religion, their gentle world, and I felt uncomfortable with the Christian references. If an author uses a well-establish myth, then he should be true to those legends. (I.e., Avalon authors Marion Zimmer Bradley, Nicole Evelina.)
My editor friends read my posts, and gently point out errors. One cannot self-edit. It is impossible. Self-publishing is a slippery slope. You need to pay a fantastic editor, which adds to the costs. In fact, some of the most terrible books I have read are self-published. I remember reading one book with nearly a dozen mistakes on the first page. As a retired teacher, it was painful reading this book. I kept having to reread to determine the meaning of the sentence. Also, adverbs are sadly lacking in several spots. This could be characterization, however. It was most jarring.
You're the most stubborn woman I ever known! ...she did not agree with hi decision."
About the author
Mark Piggott enlisted in the U.S. Navy in 1983, beginning a 23-year career. He served on three aircraft carriers and various duty stations as a Navy Journalist before attaining the rank of Chief Journalist. Now retired, he is the public affairs officer for Naval Weapons Station Yorktown, Va. His first novel, “Forever Avalon,” was published in 2009. He and his wife, Georgiene, live in Newport News, Va. They have three children.
It was a bit of a trek (2-hour drive), but we made the day an adventure. I hope I haven't bored my reader buddies with the photos, but I like to save them and post them. This is the end of them. Poor hubby drives in order for me to take pictures and can't enjoy the view.
What helped me was taking photos of the plant info! I bought 9 potted plants and had a wonderful time. They are all safely in the ground. We had a cold front move in from the Arctic, and woke to 5 C. this morning. I think they will be OK.
Hubby loves his trains. Here are some, many tagged!
There were two interesting houses. One backing directly on the track. The other up on the hill, with hay bales setting up a barrier between the house and the tracks.